The Information Machine
ConcludedRan 1 dayin the edition since 22 Oct 20264 sourcesupdated 22 Oct 2026

Meta Muse GhostShares privacy flaw

The gist

Latest: Meta Muse pauses share feature after 6,800+ private chats exposed via DNS

The flaw allowed anyone with access to public DNS lookup tools to find and open private Muse conversations without ever receiving a share link, exposing sensitive personal and business data. Meta suspended the feature after public disclosure rather than after the earlier bug bounty report.

When stories like this move, I write about them in an email each morning.

One free email each morning, around 8 AM US Eastern.

The full picture

Meta paused its Muse AI assistant's conversation-sharing feature after security firm Claroc found that more than 6,800 shared chats were discoverable through public passive DNS lookup services without needing the original link. The exposure stems from how Muse constructs share URLs: the conversation title is embedded in a subdomain alongside a short random code. Passive DNS services log address lookups the first time a page is opened and publish the full URL in searchable databases, making the random code itself retrievable. Ars Technica reported Claroc performed the enumeration using a single query. Among the pages accessed were a job candidate's prep notes for a confidential AI lab call, an internal revenue review, a loan application, a bank fraud alert, real-estate data, and a staff vacation calendar. Claroc labeled the exposed pages 'GhostShares,' describing them as 'pages that open for people who were never handed the link, and that those people can find on their own.' Claroc's CTO said the flaw appeared to be intentional design rather than a coding error, and that Meta did not respond to the firm's outreach before publication. Claroc reported the issue via Meta's bug bounty program on October 8, 2026. Meta paused the sharing feature roughly one day after Claroc published its findings, describing the response as suspending the feature while reviewing it and considering changes. The disclosure sits alongside Zuckerberg's description of Muse as 'built from the ground up for privacy and security.'

How it developed
First in the edition · 22 October 2026
21 October 2026in the 22 Oct edition

Claroc published findings that Meta's Muse AI assistant built share URLs by embedding the conversation title in a subdomain paired with a short random code, making links discoverable through passive DNS lookup services without the link ever being shared.

Using public DNS tools, Claroc enumerated more than 6,800 exposed addresses and found sensitive material including loan applications, internal revenue reviews, and job candidate prep notes among a sample of a few hundred. Claroc, which reported the issue through Meta's bug bounty program on October 8 and said Meta did not respond, called the flaw intentional design rather than a coding error. Meta paused the sharing feature roughly one day after Claroc published its findings.

20 October 2026

Claroc published its findings; Meta paused the conversation-sharing feature roughly one day later

3 October 2026

Muse reported to have reached millions of downloads amid growing European and U.S. regulatory scrutiny of its data practices.

28 September 2026

Analysis published finding Muse lacks required EU compliance documents and that its cross-service data combination faces DMA Article 5(2) scrutiny.

9 September 2026

Muse launched at $20-$100/month with privacy controls and a planned encrypted version

Sources

Get the daily email

When stories like this move, I write about them in an email each morning.

One free email each morning, around 8 AM US Eastern.

See the latest edition · Privacy